Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Jinliang Zhao ( jlzhao@shou.edu.cn ) Academic editor: Amy Deacon
© 2025 Shoujie Tang, Ying Xing, Temesgen Tola Geletu, Jinliang Zhao.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Tang S, Xing Y, Geletu TT, Zhao J (2025) Phenotypic plasticity in life-history characteristics of the invasive redbelly tilapia (Coptodon zillii) in Shuikou Reservoir, Minjiang River, China. Aquatic Invasions 20(3): 391-410. https://doi.org/10.3391/ai.2025.20.3.161320
|
In recent decades, the redbelly tilapia (Coptodon zillii) has become one of the most serious invasive alien fish species worldwide. The successful invasion of this fish may largely depend on the plasticity of its life-history traits. In order to explore the life-history traits of the invasive population of C. zillii, we chose Shuikou Reservoir of Minjiang River, China, as a typical invasive habitat, and 1,041 specimens were collected monthly from March 2023 to February 2024. Life-history traits were systematically investigated. The results showed that the entire population consists of individuals from age 1 to age 6, with the highest percentage (95.10%) of younger individuals at 1–2 years old. The sex ratio of males to females was 1.05:1. The equation of the length-weight relationship was W = 0.048*L2.938, and the parameters of von Bertalanffy growth equation were L∞= 32.937 cm, W∞= 1381.010 g, k = 0.131, and t0 = -2.056. The breeding season ranged from March to November, and the minimum sexually mature standard lengths of females and males were 8.7 and 9.0 cm, respectively. Mean absolute fecundity was 3854.38±254.43 eggs, while mean relative fecundity to standard length and body weight were 301.95±16.94 eggs/cm and 60.44±3.56 eggs/g, respectively. These results indicated that the population of C. zillii in Shuikou Reservoir presented characteristics such as a high proportion of young individuals, low growth rate, long spawning season, high fecundity, and smaller size at first maturity compared with the native and other invasive populations. Both opportunistic and equilibrium life-history strategies might have contributed to their successful invasion, and there is a potential risk of further population expansion.
Age structure, fecundity, growth traits, invasion, reproductive strategies
Biological invasions represent a significant aspect of global change (
Coptodon zillii, also referred to as the redbelly tilapia, is classified within the Cichliformes, Cichlidae, and is indigenous to Africa and the Middle East (
The successful invasion of exotic fishes has been demonstrated to be influenced by a multitude of factors, including the intrinsic characteristics of the species in question, the environmental conditions prevailing at the site of the invasion, and the specific circumstances of the invasion event (
During the 1990s,
The invasive population of bluegill sunfish (Lepomis macrochirus) in Qiandao Lake, China, is distinguished by an opportunistic life-history, characterised by early sexual maturity, a prolonged reproductive period, high fecundity and a higher proportion of females (
Coptodon zillii is a substrate spawner with a relatively early age of sexual maturity and a strong sense of territoriality (
The Shuikou Reservoir is a narrow and deep riverine reservoir located in the middle reaches of the main stream of the Minjiang River. It has a total capacity of 2.6×109 m3, making it the largest reservoir in Fujian Province. Following the water storage in March 1993, C. zillii was once farmed on a large scale around the reservoir. Escape of redbelly tilapia into the reservoir occurs from time to time due to poor culture management. In recent years, tilapia farming has ceased in the vicinity of the reservoir. However, the population of C. zillii within the reservoir has exhibited a notable increase year by year. In certain areas of the reservoir, C. zillii have become a dominant taxon (
The sampling site (26°40'N, 118°49'E) is located in Zhanghu Town, Yanping District, Nanping City, Fujian Province (Figure
Immediately following capture, the samples were anaesthetised with MS-222 (100 mg/L), after which routine biological measurements were conducted on site. These included standard length (accurate to 0.1 cm) and weight (accurate to 0.01 g). Gender of specimens were distinguished using the morphology of the genital papilla and macroscopic examination of gonads. Gonadal development was divided into six stages (I–VI) according to the criteria of
The scales of specimens were employed as the material for age identification. Five to ten scales of each specimen were taken from between the lateral line and first dorsal fin. They were cleaned, fixed between the two glass slides, soaked with drops of alcohol, dried and preserved. And the total scale radius and the radius of each annulus were measured under a dissection microscope, with annuli identified using criteria of
The length-weight relationship was established using the equation W = aLb (
The monthly gonado-somatic index (GSI) was used to reflect the degree of gonadal development, and the intensity of reproductive activity was assessed based on the monthly trend of the GSI, estimated by the formula GSI (%) = 100×(Wg/WE), where Wg and WE are the gonadal weight (g) and the eviscerated weight (g), respectively. The fecundity of C. zillii was estimated by the standard gravimetric method. We obtained and weighed three systematic subsamples (5–20% of total ovary weight) from the anterior, middle, and posterior sections of the ovary. And the fecundity was calculated according to the following formulas: F = nWO/w, Fw = F/WE, FL = F/L. The variables are defined as follows: F is absolute fecundity; n is the number of eggs counted; WO is the weight of the ovary (g); w is the weight of the subsamples of the ovary (g); Fw is the relative fecundity to body weight; WE is the eviscerated weight (g); FL is the relative fecundity to standard length; and L is the standard length (cm). Ten ovaries on stage IV were selected for analysis of the diameter of the eggs. Eggs were extracted from the anterior, middle, and posterior sections of the ovaries, which had been fixed in a 5% formaldehyde solution. The eggs were observed and photographed under a dissection microscope. The diameters of eggs were measured under a stereomicroscope using imaging software, with an accuracy of 0.01 mm.
Statistical analysis and graphical representation of the data were conducted in Microsoft Excel 2019, SPSS 27.0.1 and ORIGIN 2021, respectively. The chi-square test was utilised to ascertain whether the sex ratio of females to males was in accordance with the expected 1:1 ratio. Significance of difference was tested using independent samples t-test and one-way analysis of variance, with a significance level α of 0.05.
The entire population consists of individuals from age 1 to age 6, with the highest percentage (78.29%) of younger individuals at 1 years old. Individuals of age 2 constitute the second largest age group, which accounted for 16.81% of the total number of samples. The maximum ages of the female and male samples were age 4 and 6, respectively (Suppl. material
A total of 533 males and 508 females were collected for analysis in this study. The standard length and body weight of all samples ranged from 7.5 to 23.0 cm and 15.49 to 463.15 g, respectively. The length-weight relationship for all samples was determined to be W = 0.048*L2.938(R²= 0.903) (Figure
The estimated asymptotic length (L∞) of C. zillii population (all samples) was determined to be 32.937 cm, while the asymptotic body weight (W∞) was found to be 1381.010 g (Suppl. material
The growth rate and growth acceleration equations for standard length and body weight of C. zillii are presented in Suppl. material
Of the 1041 specimens examined, 158 had reached sexual maturity (gonads at stage IV or V) (Figure
The gonadal weights of females ranged from 0.7 to 15.62 g, with a mean gonadal weight of 1.14 g. The gonadal weights of males ranged from 0.03 to 6.48 g, with a mean gonadal weight of 0.21 g (Suppl. material
Annual changes in gonadal developmental stages of female samples (a), gonado-somatic index (GSI) (b) and distribution of egg diameter in stage IV ovaries (c) of Coptodon zillii in Shuikou Reservoir. Temp denotes water temperature. The symbol ♀ and ♂ denote GSI of female and male samples, respectively. Error bars denote standard error.
The relative fecundity to standard length of females (n = 86) ranged from 85.48 to 833.09 eggs/cm, with a mean value of 298.54 eggs/cm (Table
| Age | Sample size | Relative fecundity to standard length (eggs/cm) | Relative fecundity to body weight (eggs/g) | Absolute fecundity (eggs) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean±SE | Range | Mean±SE | Range | Mean±SE | Range | ||
| 1 | 44 | 253.74±19.26b | 99.44~595.87 | 67.94±5.63a | 18.69~168.22 | 2765.70±207.68c | 991~7269 |
| 2 | 30 | 333.26±32.47ab | 85.48~833.09 | 56.61±5.24ab | 21.92~152.39 | 4366.76±443.03ab | 982~13413 |
| 3 | 11 | 400.67±48.42a | 93.58~402.46 | 42.57±4.70b | 26.74~73.65 | 6540.90±845.27a | 4125~11505 |
| 4 | 1 | 455.27 | NA | 31.12 | NA | 8513 | NA |
| Total | 86 | 298.54 | 85.48~833.09 | 59.89 | 18.69~168.22 | 3854.38 | 982~13413 |
The mean egg diameter was 1.52±0.45 mm, with a bimodal distribution of egg diameter (Figure
The age structure of fish populations is an important ecological characteristic, and changes in age structure reflect, to a certain extent, the adjustment of life-history strategies of fish populations in the face of ecological changes (
Plasticity in growth traits has been demonstrated in bleak (Alburnus alburnus) (
Comparison of growth characteristics of Coptodon zillii from native and introduced range.
| Population source | Sampling site | Country | Standard length/cm | b | k | L ∞/cm | W ∞/g | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Native | Wadi El-Raiyan Lakes | Egypt | 8~30.5 | 3.088 | 0.49 | 33.5 | 819.33 |
|
| Native | Nozha Hydrodrom Lake | Egypt | NA | 2.885 | 0.203 | 33.38 | 713.4 |
|
| Native | Timsah Lake | Egypt | 7~16 (female) | 2.975 | 0.680 | 17.83 | 109.54 |
|
| 8~21 (male) | 3.005 | 0.320 | 22.05 | 201.74 | ||||
| Native | Umhfein Lake | Libya | 15~27 | 3.228 | 0.234 | 28.81 | 565.78 |
|
| Introduced | Garmat Ali River | Iraq | 7~22 | 3.237 | 0.168 | 28.4 | 455.65 |
|
| Introduced | Haebaru Reservoir | Japan | 3.1~13.8 (female) | NA | 0.67 | NA | NA |
|
| 3.3~16.8 (male) | NA | 0.36 | NA | NA | ||||
| Introduced | Shuikou Reservoir, Minjiang River | China | 7.5~23.0 | 2.938 | 0.131 | 32.94 | 1381.01 | present study |
Successful reproductive strategies and their plasticity are crucial during the invasion process for fishes (Garcia-Berthou 2007). Typically, this plasticity involves higher reproductive investment (e.g. higher absolute fecundity, longer spawning seasons, earlier age at sexual maturity, etc.) compared to native populations (
The onset of fish spawning and the duration of the reproductive period are usually dependent on temperature and photoperiod. However, some studies have shown that reproductive events in the same water body are not always directly related to these environmental parameters (
Comparison of reproductive characteristics of Coptodon zillii from native and introduced range.
| Population source | Sampling site | Country | Breeding season | Average absolute fecundity/eggs | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Native | Damietta branch of the River Nile | Egypt | May-Sep | 3036 |
|
| Native | Lake Timsah | Egypt | Jan-Aug | NA |
|
| Native | Abu Qir bay | Egypt | NA | 2139 |
|
| Native | Lake Kinneret | Israel | Apr-Aug | NA |
|
| Introduced | Lake Naivasha | Kenya | year-round | 6606 |
|
| Introduced | Lake Zwai | Ethiopia | year-round | NA |
|
| Introduced | Garmat Ali River | Iraq | NA | 2224 |
|
| Introduced | Victoria Nyanza | Kenya | NA | 3757.17 | Lowe (McConnell) 1955 |
| Introduced | Al-Swaib marshes | Iraq | Jun-Aug | 3793 |
|
| Introduced | Aquarium keeping | Britain | NA | 3606 |
|
| Introduced | Pond feeding | Kenya | NA | 2359 |
|
| Introduced | Dongjiang River | China | May-Oct | 7991 |
|
| Introduced | Shanmai Reservoir | China | Apr-Sep | 4009.85 |
|
| Introduced | Shuikou Reservoir, Minjiang River | China | Mar-Nov | 3854.38 | present study |
Life-history theory (
Fish fecundity is a widely used indicator of reproductive capacity in breeding populations, serving as an adaptive compensation to external environmental factors (
The life-histories of fish are more flexible than those of thermostats, and often adjust in response to changes in environmental stressors in order to maximise fitness (
Given the extent of the expansion of C. zillii in Shuikou Reservoir, eradication is no longer a viable option. In light of the findings of this study, the following recommendations are put forth as a means of effectively curbing the rapid spread of this species. The first step is to conduct tracking and monitoring of the invasive populations of C. zillii. Advanced technologies such as environmental DNA (eDNA) meta-barcoding are recommended to monitor low-density populations and combined with acoustic telemetry to track dispersal patterns. Long-term monitoring must assess seasonal abundance shifts, particularly in thermally favorable zones (>24°C), where spawning aggregations occur. The second step is to use a variety of measures to effectively control the invasive populations of C. zillii. Regular and intensive fishing and removal of the redbelly tilapia by local people mobilised by the fisheries authorities should be carried out, so as to reduce the size of its population. At the same time, during the breeding season (March to November) of the C. zillii, the fishing intensity is increased in the waters where it nests and spawns to control the number of juveniles. It is recommended that the protection and restoration of native piscivores (e.g., Culter alburnus, Siniperca chuatsi, Siniperca scherzeri) in Shuikou Reservoir be strengthened. Scientific stocking of native piscivore in this reservoir should be put into practice based on a comprehensive resource assessment. This will inhibit the number of eggs and fry of C. zillii and reduce the density of its juveniles through predation and competitive effects. Breeding and releasing of indigenous fish (e.g. Channa maculates) with similar life-history characteristics to C. zillii should be considered. Furthermore, the stocking of large-size indigenous fish into the habitat of C. zillii may result in the reduction of the population size of C. zillii due to interspecific competition for resources. The third step is habitat restoration in waters invaded by C. zillii. A comprehensive assessment of the invaded ecosystem, including water quality analyses, biodiversity surveys, and mapping of C. zillii distribution, must be conducted to determine the extent of the invasion and the specific habitats degraded. Displaced or threatened native species should be reintroduced or protected through breeding programmes and habitat enhancement measures. Ecosystem stability should be maintained through restoration of aquatic vegetation at the site of invasion.
In this study, we analysed the life-history traits of C. zillii in Shuikou Reservoir, Minjiang River. The ecological mechanisms underlying its successful invasion in terms of growth, reproduction and age composition were preliminarily explored. We found that C. zillii possessed opportunistic (e.g., early maturation, prolonged reproductive period and high fecundity) life-history strategies. On the other hand, previous studies have demonstrated that they also possess parental care (
S. Tang and J. Zhao conceived and designed the study. S. Tang and Y. Xing collected the data. S. Tang conducted the data analysis and wrote the manuscript with contributions from T. Geletu. All authors contributed to draft manuscripts and approved the final manuscript for publication.
Shoujie Tang https://orcid.org/0009-0000-6154-7235
Temesgen Tola Geletu https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7261-5539
This study was supported by the National Key Research and Development Program of China (2022YFC2601302).
The experimental protocol was approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC) of Shanghai Ocean University (permit number: SHOUDW2024085), and complies with the Guidelines on Ethical Treatment of Experimental Animals established by the Ministry of Science and Technology, China.
We are grateful to Mr. Honggui Huang (Fisheries Research Institute of Fujian, China), Mr. Yunyi Yang (Department of Agriculture and Rural Affairs of Yanping District, Nanping City, Fujian Province, China), and Mr. Xueli Chen (professional fisherman in Yanping District, Nanping City, Fujian Province, China) for their selfless assistance during the sample collection. We sincerely appreciate the reviewers for dedicating their time and effort to provide valuable comments and suggestions, which have significantly enhanced the quality of our manuscript.
Standard length (SL), body weight (BW), eviscerated weight (EW), gonad weight (GW) and overall sex ratio of Coptodon zillii at all ages in Shuikou Reservoir
Data type: docx
von Bertalanffy growth equation of Coptodon zillii in Shuikou Reservoir
Data type: docx